Rentals
· Rentivaro Editorial Team

Rentivaro is an independent property listing aggregator. We may earn a commission when you click through.

4231 SE Madison St: Big House, Serious Monthly Rent

This 2,844-square-foot Portland rental offers three bedrooms, central air, and a garage for $3,995 per month, plus possible fees.

Advertisement

30-Second Take

$3,995 per month gets you a lot of house at 4231 SE Madison St: 2,844 square feet, three bedrooms, two bathrooms, central air, in-unit laundry, and an attached garage. The listing says 1.5 baths in its main details, while the supplied property data lists 2.0, so confirm the bathroom count before applying. The bigger issue is value: this is a large single-family rental, but the listing provides no price history, neighborhood rent comparison, or detail on utilities and fees. It had been on Zillow for five days and had received nine contacts when checked, which suggests interest without proving that the rent is a bargain.

4231 SE Madison St

A spacious three-bedroom rental with central air and an attached garage, but the $3,995 rent and inconsistent bathroom count deserve scrutiny.

You will stay on this site

Property Details

The property is a single-family residence at 4231 SE Madison St, Portland, OR 97215. The listed rent is $3,995 per month, and Zillow warns that required fees may apply. It is advertised as available November 16, with cats and small dogs allowed.

  • Bedrooms: 3
  • Bathrooms: 1.5 according to the listing; the supplied data says 2.0
  • Size: 2,844 square feet
  • Parking: Attached garage
  • Climate: Central air and forced-air heating
  • Laundry: In-unit
  • Pets: Cats and small dogs accepted, subject to the landlord's terms
  • Availability: November 16
  • Listing activity: Five days on Zillow and nine contacts at the time of the page snapshot

The listing includes 32 photos and an open house scheduled for Sunday, November 15, from 11 a.m. to noon. No price reduction is shown, and no prior rent amount appears in the supplied listing content. That means there is no evidence yet that the landlord is negotiating or testing a lower price.

For commute planning, the address sits in southeast Portland near the Mt. Tabor area. The listing does not provide a commute estimate, transit details, walk score, school assignment, or nearby amenity list, so renters should check those independently before treating the location as a lifestyle win. The attached garage is useful in a city where parking can become a daily nuisance, but the listing does not say whether driveway or street parking is also available.

Where It Wins

The space is the obvious advantage. At 2,844 square feet, this is much larger than the typical three-bedroom rental layout, giving a household room for a home office, playroom, guest space, or storage. You are not paying this rent for a compact apartment with a token third bedroom.

  • ✅ Nearly 2,800 square feet of living space for a three-bedroom household
  • ✅ Attached garage parking, which is more useful than an unreserved street spot
  • ✅ Central air for warmer Portland days
  • ✅ In-unit laundry, so there is no shared laundry-room chore
  • ✅ Cats and small dogs are permitted according to the listing
  • ✅ Single-family privacy rather than shared walls in a large apartment building

The combination of central air, garage parking, and in-unit laundry is stronger than the basic amenity package found in many older Portland rentals. The home also has a practical household profile: three bedrooms can support a family, roommates, or a couple that needs dedicated work space.

The surprising detail is not a hidden luxury feature. It is the amount of space per bedroom. At roughly 948 square feet per bedroom, the property has enough capacity to feel like a house rather than an oversized apartment. That extra room may justify the rent for people who would otherwise pay for separate office or storage space elsewhere.

Watch Out For

$3,995 is a serious monthly commitment. Before comparing it with other Portland rentals, ask for the full move-in cost, including security deposit, pet charges, application fees, utility responsibility, and any recurring service fees. Zillow's displayed price may not include required charges.

  • ❌ The rent is high enough that missing fee details matter
  • ❌ The listing conflicts on the bathroom count: 1.5 versus 2.0
  • ❌ No price history or rent comparison is provided
  • ❌ No school, transit, walkability, or commute information appears on the page
  • ❌ The listing does not explain the garage dimensions, storage, or additional parking
  • ❌ Pet approval is limited to cats and small dogs and may carry extra charges

The bathroom discrepancy is not a tiny editorial error. A household choosing between this property and another three-bedroom home may reasonably value two full bathrooms, especially with roommates or children. Confirm whether the second bathroom has a shower or tub, and ask which rooms are included in the advertised square footage.

There is also a timing issue. The home is listed as available November 16, immediately after the advertised open house. That can be convenient, but it leaves little room to delay if the landlord expects a quick decision. Do not let the open-house schedule push you into applying before seeing the lease terms and total monthly cost.

Compared with a smaller rental from a manager such as Portland Property Management, this home may offer more privacy and space but fewer clearly published details. Compared with a large apartment community, it should provide more room and a garage, but it may lack predictable amenity information, on-site maintenance details, and transparent fee schedules.

Rent It If...

This is best for a household of three to five people with a monthly housing budget comfortably above $4,000, at least one car, and a real need for extra rooms. A family that wants central air, garage parking, and space for work or storage will get more practical value here than a renter who simply wants a third bedroom.

It also works for two professionals who need separate offices and do not want apartment living. The property makes less sense for a renter who spends most of the week downtown, relies on transit, or wants a low-maintenance lease with every fee clearly listed upfront. The listing does not provide enough commute or transit information to assume the location will be convenient for a car-free routine.

Pet owners should confirm breed, weight, deposit, and monthly pet-rent rules before applying. “Cats, small dogs OK” is helpful, but it is not the same as unconditional pet approval.

Final Verdict

Choose this if you are a family or roommate household that needs nearly 2,844 square feet, an attached garage, central air, and at least one home office, and you can handle $3,995 per month before possible fees. Skip this if your budget is close to the advertised rent, you need two confirmed full bathrooms, or you want a rental with transparent pricing and commute details already provided.

The property has the bones of a comfortable Portland home, but the listing has not yet proved that the rent matches the neighborhood or the condition. Ask about the bathroom count, total move-in cost, utilities, parking, and lease terms at the open house. For another rental review where renovated space comes with a different practical compromise, compare it with 3332 Altadena Ave: Renovated Space, Tight Parking Trade-Off.

You might also like

More articles